Showing posts with label Chennai. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Chennai. Show all posts
Saturday, January 3, 2015
Saturday, January 4, 2014
NGT restrained:
HC puts brakes on NGT, says it cant act on its own
TNN, Jan 4, 2014, 07.00AM IST
CHENNAI: Clipping the wings of the southern bench of the National Green Tribunal (NGT), which has been taking suo motu cognizance of issues at will and issuing directions, the Madras high court has restrained the forum from initiating proceedings on its own.
NGT is not a substitute for high court in all respects, said a division bench of Justice Satish K Agnihotri and Justice K K Sasidharan, adding: "The tribunal has to function within the parameters laid down by the National Green Tribunal Act, 2010. It should act within the four corners of the statute. There is no indication in the act or the rules made thereunder with regard to the power of NGT to initiate suo motu proceedings against anyone, including statutory authorities."
The bench was passing orders on a PIL filed by advocate P Sundararajan, who took objection to the suo motu proceedings of the NGT and said the tribunal had been taking up matters on its own and adjudicating them without any authority.
His counsel M Radhakrishnan said the tribunal's suo motu proceedings had no legal sanctity and as such, it should be restrained from initiating such proceedings. NGT was constituted for effective and expeditious disposal of cases relating to environmental protection and forest conservation, including enforcement of legal rights relating to environment.
Finding substance in the submissions, the judges said: "Provisions of the Civil Procedure Code are extended to the tribunal only for a very limited purpose. It is true that the tribunal is given power to regulate its own procedure and it is not bound by the strict rules of evidence. However, that would not convert the tribunal into a high court, to initiate suo motu proceedings." The bench, citing the SC rulings, said while courts were entrusted with the inherent power for administration of justice in general, tribunals are established under a statute and are meant to adjudicate disputes arising under the particular legislation. While all courts are tribunals, all tribunals are not courts, it said.
Adjourning the matter to January 22, the judges said: "There shall be an interim injunction restraining the NGT, southern bench, from initiating suo motu proceedings."
NGT is not a substitute for high court in all respects, said a division bench of Justice Satish K Agnihotri and Justice K K Sasidharan, adding: "The tribunal has to function within the parameters laid down by the National Green Tribunal Act, 2010. It should act within the four corners of the statute. There is no indication in the act or the rules made thereunder with regard to the power of NGT to initiate suo motu proceedings against anyone, including statutory authorities."
The bench was passing orders on a PIL filed by advocate P Sundararajan, who took objection to the suo motu proceedings of the NGT and said the tribunal had been taking up matters on its own and adjudicating them without any authority.
His counsel M Radhakrishnan said the tribunal's suo motu proceedings had no legal sanctity and as such, it should be restrained from initiating such proceedings. NGT was constituted for effective and expeditious disposal of cases relating to environmental protection and forest conservation, including enforcement of legal rights relating to environment.
Finding substance in the submissions, the judges said: "Provisions of the Civil Procedure Code are extended to the tribunal only for a very limited purpose. It is true that the tribunal is given power to regulate its own procedure and it is not bound by the strict rules of evidence. However, that would not convert the tribunal into a high court, to initiate suo motu proceedings." The bench, citing the SC rulings, said while courts were entrusted with the inherent power for administration of justice in general, tribunals are established under a statute and are meant to adjudicate disputes arising under the particular legislation. While all courts are tribunals, all tribunals are not courts, it said.
Adjourning the matter to January 22, the judges said: "There shall be an interim injunction restraining the NGT, southern bench, from initiating suo motu proceedings."
Tuesday, August 6, 2013
UPDATION OF COURT/TRIBUNALS INFORMATION AT GOVERNMENT WEBSITES FOR THE BENEFIT OF PUBLIC
On 05th August 2013, there was a case posted
before National Green Tribunal (Southern Zone), Chennai [APPLICATION No.
90/2013, Indian council for Enviro Legal Action & 2 others Vs. UOI &
230 others]. The said case is an
environmental issue case transferred from A.P. High Court to the Green Bench at
Chennai. To locate the address of the
Tribunal, several problems were faced by several litigants who were from A.P., and most of them are first-time visitors to the Tribunal. Astonishingly, there is no mention about this Tribunal even at Supreme Court website, leave alone
Madras High Court website. Google search
also proved futile.
The
Southern Bench of the National Green Tribunal (NGT), the first permanent zonal
bench, which is operational since December 2012 cover four southern States and
the Union Territories of Puducherry and Lakshadweep. Already, environment-related cases in the
Green Benches of the High Courts of the southern States were being transferred
to the NGT’s southern zonal branch. The objective would be to provide effective
and expeditious disposal of cases relating to environment protection and
conservation of forests and other natural resources, including enforcement of
legal rights and compensation or damages in environment matters. NGT has got original and appellate
jurisdiction on matters pertaining to seven Acts related to water, air, forest
conservation, environment protection and biological diversity. Being such an important Tribunal,
non-availability of it’s web-presence/search engines absence about its’ location
is a matter of concern!
If all the Courts/Tribunals address (including phone
numbers) are displayed at appropriate Government websites (including SC
website), it will be useful to the litigants.
The Tribunal is located at 950/1, TNPCB Building, Poonamallee High Road, Arumbakkam,
Chennai – 600106. (From Koyambedu
Bus Stand it is reachable by share-Auto).
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
